Art’s Resilience in a Stormy Market: Tariffs, CDS, and the Future of Art Finance
- Palette
- 3 days ago
- 4 min read
The global financial landscape is navigating choppy waters, driven by President Trump’s new tariffs, a resurgence in credit default swaps (CDS), soaring bond yields, and a US credit rating downgrade. These forces are reverberating through the art market, impacting collectors, enthusiasts, financiers, and investors. For those exploring art-backed lending—like the solutions Palette aims to offer—these shifts present a mix of challenges and opportunities. Let’s dive into how these economic changes are reshaping the art world and the potential of art as a financial asset, with a focus on its enduring value in turbulent times.
Tariffs: A Costly Brushstroke for Art Trade
On April 2, 2025, President Trump unveiled his “Liberation Day” tariffs, imposing a 10% base rate on imports from most countries, with duties as high as 152.5% on certain Chinese goods starting April 9, according to Artnet. Artworks are currently exempt from US tariffs under the Berman Amendment, which classifies them as “informational materials,” as detailed by The Art Newspaper. However, retaliatory tariffs from trading partners are complicating the picture. The UK has proposed duties on US paintings, drawings, and sculptures under 100 years old, outlined in a 417-page list, while Canada has slapped a 25% tax on $21 billion of US goods, including decorative works, since March.
These trade barriers are hiking costs for cross-border art transactions. Dealers are feeling the squeeze, with a Western New York gallerist opting out of Art Toronto fair due to financial risks. Rising expenses for materials like wood for crates, driven by tariff-related supply chain disruptions, could further pressure art valuations. For art-backed lending, this uncertainty may lead lenders to lower loan-to-value (LTV) ratios, as collateral values become less predictable. Palette’s vision of focusing on mid-tier artworks—priced between $50,000 and $1 million—aligns with the market’s most resilient segment, offering collectors a way to unlock liquidity without selling in a volatile trade environment.
Credit Default Swaps: A Risky Undercurrent
Credit default swaps, financial tools that hedge against debt defaults, are climbing to levels reminiscent of the 2008 crisis, when their notional value hit $62.2 trillion. Though today’s CDS market is smaller—around $8.8 trillion in 2020, per industry estimates—the uptick signals growing concerns about credit risk. In 2008, CDS amplified systemic instability, triggering a credit crunch that curtailed lending across sectors. A similar scenario today could tighten conditions for asset-backed lending, including art-backed loans, with lenders potentially demanding higher collateral or stricter borrower criteria.
Yet, art’s low correlation with traditional financial markets, as highlighted in Deloitte and ArtTactic’s Art & Finance Report 2023, makes it a compelling asset for diversification. This resilience supports its use as collateral or an investment vehicle, whether through loans or ownership—a strategy explored in our post “Art as an Investment: Debt vs Equity”. For collectors and investors, art-backed lending offers a lifeline to liquidity, and Palette’s future-focused approach aims to make this accessible to a broader audience, beyond the ultra-wealthy.
High Bond Yields: Borrowing’s New Price Tag
Bond yields are surging, reflecting expectations of rising interest rates or inflation. As bond prices fall, yields climb, making borrowing more expensive across markets. The Art Basel and UBS Art Market Report 2025 notes that high interest rates in 2023 already dampened luxury spending, including on art. However, blue chip contemporary art’s historical performance—delivering 14% annual returns over 25 years compared to the S&P 500’s 9.5%, per Yieldstreet—keeps it in demand as a store of value.
For art-backed lending, higher yields mean costlier loans, which could deter some collectors from leveraging their collections. Yet, the mid-tier market, where 98% of dealer sales occur under $1 million, remains a bright spot. This segment’s strength, driven by demand for affordable works, supports stable collateral values. Palette enters this space to service **mid-tier collectors and galleries, aiming to provide flexible financing options that harness art’s enduring appeal in a high-cost borrowing environment.
US Credit Downgrade: A Liquidity Squeeze
The US credit rating downgrade underscores broader economic strain, increasing government borrowing costs and tightening credit markets. This could shrink the pool of capital available for asset-backed loans, as lenders grow more cautious. In the art market, high-end sales are faltering, with a 29% drop in auction sales in 2024, per Artnet’s Mid-Year Review. Meanwhile, mid-tier artworks are thriving, with 95% of 2023 online auction transactions priced below $50,000, according to the Art Basel and UBS Art Market Report 2025.
Art-backed lending faces challenges in this tighter credit landscape, as lenders may require larger collateral buffers or focus on borrowers with robust financials. However, art’s role as an inflation hedge, coupled with a projected $40 billion art-backed lending market by 2025 (Deloitte), underscores its financial relevance. Palette’s vision is to support this demand, along with collectors, galleries, and artists who see art as both a cultural and financial asset, even as credit conditions tighten.
Art’s Enduring Value in Uncertain Times
The convergence of tariffs, CDS spikes, high bond yields, and a credit downgrade creates a complex environment for the art market, yet its resilience shines through. The mid-tier segment, where 85% of online auction values in 2023 came from works under $250,000, is gaining momentum, driven by collectors prioritizing value and stability. Art-backed lending remains a vital tool, with 43% of high-net-worth collectors using credit to finance acquisitions, per the Art Basel and UBS Art Market Report 2025. This trend reflects art’s growing role as a liquid asset, capable of unlocking capital without the need for selling cherished pieces.
Economic uncertainty also highlights art’s unique position. Its low correlation with financial markets makes it a hedge against inflation and volatility, appealing to investors seeking diversification—provided global commerce faces fewer restrictions. As tariffs and trade barriers rise, this correlation could weaken if cross-border art flows falter, impacting valuations. Still, the art-backed lending market’s growth—from $29.2-$34.1 billion in 2023 to a potential $40 billion by year-end—signals robust demand for liquidity solutions. As Palette prepares to enter this space, the focus is clear: empowering a wider range of collectors to leverage art’s financial potential, particularly in the vibrant mid-tier market.
Comments